Pdf minority shareholder protection in georgia and germany a. Pdf this paper performs an analysis of the regulation regarding minority shareholders protection in romania. Its also been accepted, until recently, that minority shareholders owed each other no such considerationthe point being that minority. The two major oppression of minority shareholders are from the management and the majority shareholders. Minority shareholder protection is a central part of the corporate governance. As per the companies act 1956, shareholders who hold the majority of shares, rule the company.
Traditionally, minority shareholders are said not to have the right, or the standing, to initiate proceedings against the controllers of the company, because in the eyes of the law the minority shareholders are said not to be the appropriate persons to bring such proceedings, except in the situation of first, fraud on the minority shareholders, and second, controllers illegal, or. Designed and printed at united nations, geneva 40538 e november 2014 3,452 hrpub127. Shareholders of closelyheld corporations may address and resolve such difficulties by entering into shareholder agreements that contain buysell, first refusal, or redemption. How to enhance minority shareholder protection in nigeria. So, for example, the right to participate and vote at general meetings may be only as good as, and be partially dependent. Protection of minority shareholders against unfairly prejudicial conduct by the majority shareholders 22 march 2018 minority shareholders in both companies and close corporations members enjoy a measure of protection against unfairly prejudicial, unjust or inequitable acts that arise from the conduct of majority shareholders or the company. Such a position can be particularly detrimental where shareholders are in the minority and find themselves being prejudiced by the majority shareholders. Minority shareholders may protect themselves contractually. The protection of minority shareholders rights must be understood within the context of the rules set by the act, the common law, the memorandum of incorporation moi of the company and the shareholders agreement, in the event that a company has a shareholders agreement. Although great progress has been achieved, especially from the revisions of the company law, the provisions in the new laws may still not be good enough to yield thorough protection for the minority shareholders in china. This exercise outlines the protection available for minority shareholders and trains your reading and vocabulary skills. Weber many hong kong companies, including listed companies, are controlled by a small group of shareholders with family ties.
Many hong kong companies, including many listed companies, originate from family business and controlled by small group of people with strong family relation cheung, 2000. The corporations are controlled by the shareholders. Rights of minority shareholders under companies act, 20. Crosslisting on the nyse or nasdaq subjects a nonus firm to a number of provisions of us securities law. Minority shareholders control rights and the quality of corporate decisions in weak investor protection countries. Protecting minority shareholders different actions for.
There is a broad variety of reasons that majority shareholders have to rather see the minority shareholder go. In this modern and advance era of competition, corporate sector plays an extremely important role in the development of a state by strengthening its economy and ensuring the economic stability. A direct consequence of the majority rule in corporate administration is the fact that the minority shareholders are at risk of exploitation by the majority. Legal rights of minority shareholders legal beagle. Corporations are owned by shareholders who may themselves be companies. Minority shareholders control rights and the quality of. In order to create a holistic picture of the oppression remedy within this dissertation, one must first start with the older of the two remedies, in order to appreciate the changes brought about. Minority shareholder rights and protections 15 section 1. In companies act, 1956, the protection for the minority shareholders from oppression and mismanagement have been provided under section 397 an application to be made to company law board for relief in cases of oppression and 398 an application to be made to company law board for relief in cases of oppression. The justifications for this discrepancy are explored and it is suggested that the lower level of minority protection is explicable, and acceptable, once the different.
Protection of minority shareholders in listed issuers iosco is. Doc minority shareholder protection in uk company law. In order to adequately protect holders of minority interests of a corporate entity against oppressive shareholders whose actions might be at variance with the companys articles, there are several remedies and protection available to minority shareholders as. Currently the companies act 71 of 2008 the 2008 act makes provision for the protection of shareholders rights. Rights and protection of minority shareholders in thailand. The rights and responsibilities of minority shareholders.
Dispersal of shareholding in the uk gives oppressed minority. To co nclude, it is evident that protection for minority shareholders is a signi ficant aspect of corporate governance. Pdf shareholders rights and remedies comparative law. Such option is particularly effective for foreign investors who aim to set up a thai company where a majority of thai shareholding is needed. Traditionally, minority shareholders are said not to have the right, or the standing, to initiate proceedings against the controllers of the company, because in the eyes of the law the minority shareholders are said not to be the appropriate persons to bring such proceedings, except in the situation of first, fraud on the minority shareholders, and second, controllers. By jason pfister its common knowledge in the law that majority shareholders have a fiduciary responsibility to protect the interests of minority shareholders with whom they share ownership in a closelyheld corporation. Schemes have become the mechanism of choice for recommended bids in the uk, and yet they offer significantly less protection to minority shareholders than traditional bids. In this thesis, i seek to study the two oppression and the minority protection under the company law in hong kong and china. The goals identified in the consultation process leading to the adoption of the new act included achieving corporate efficiency by avoiding lockingin of minority shareholders in inefficient companies, promoting transparency by protecting shareholders rights, advancing shareholder activism and providing enhanced protection for minority shareholders.
As a result, the legal system has devised rules to protect the minority. Protection of minority shareholders in specific contexts 34 section 1. The protection of minority shareholders is one of the important topics in company law. A shareholder may own the company entirely, may own a majority of its shares or may just own a minority of shares. Objectives x to explore the duties of independent directors in corpo rate governance. To ensure adequate protection, corporate governance must specify litigation. Pdf the new legal regime on minority shareholder protection in. The protection of shareholder rights and the equitable. Rather than being concerned to protect the company, a minority shareholder in such a position is usually more concerned to protect himself personally from the adverse consequences of being a shareholder in a company with a majority shareholder managing the company in his the majority shareholder s own best interests rather than for the benefit of all shareholders. Study on minority shareholders protection publications. Shareholder agreements protecting the minority shareholder by agreement. Minority shareholder protection in georgia and germany a comparative analysis by tamar kvintradze ceu etd collection ll. Laws solicitude, it seems, is limited to minority shareholders, not minority races. Reflections on the derivative action in the uk, the usa and in china.
Some corporate officers say they have to spend more time and thought in keeping minority shareholders pacified than in operating the business. Protection of minority shareholders in the netherlands. The study includes a thorough analysis and assessment of every member states legal framework as it relates to minority shareholder protection, and it focuses on all the main categories of minority. Minority shareholder protectionin uk company law t palma introduction arguably one of the most basic principles of uk company law, the majority rule is based on the democratic notion that the daily operations of a company are rooted on the decisions made by its majority members. In canada, minority shareholder approval is also required. Purpose the purpose of this paper is to compare the response in the uk, the usa and china to the need to provide effective protection in law to disgruntled minority shareholders. Cliffe dekker hofmeyr minority shareholder protection. Pdf minority shareholders and corporate governance. Henceforth, the protection of minority shareholders becomes all the more important. Protection of minority shareholders the purpose of. In four jurisdictions, shareholders do not have any vote with respect to the creation or issuance of. Shareholder agreement protecting minority shareholders. Protection of minority shareholders in listed issuers. Minority shareholders general give company managers a rough time.
The law has therefore provided various methods for the protection of minority shareholders. Section 22 provides that the memorandum and articles of association shall constitute a contract binding the members to the terms of the memorandum and articles. Thus, there is need to protect this group of shareholders in order that their interest in the corporation. Protection of minority shareholders can have some major effect on the valuation of the firm. A study on role of independent directors in protecting the. If the law is inefficient to protect minority shareholders, it is possible for controlling shareholders to abuse company. Fiduciary duties of directors and controlling or substantial shareholders 28 section 3. Introduction the minority shareholder is one without controlling interest in a company. Shareholder protection in international investment law. Protection of minority shareholders in company law, a minority shareholder has little, if any, power over the management of the company or the distribution of its profits. It may be that there is only a disconnect on a personal level or it may be. While the rights common to all shareholders can be useful in a close corporation situation, additional rights are needed to protect minority shareholders from being oppressed by the majority shareholders. This is primarily provided for in s 163 of the 2008 act.
While numerous factors play into whether a country has a dynamic financial market, theres. To do so a comparative analysis of the regulatory frameworks for the protection of minority shareholders in kenya and the united kingdom uk will be used 1 aleksandr shkolnikov, protecting minority shareholders in emerging markets center for international private enterprise. These methods are highly factsensitive and minority shareholders are reminded to choose the correct method for addressing the specific problems. Protection of minority shareholders in a company under the companies act 20 by vishnu tandi democratic decisions are made in accordance with the majority decision and same rule was also applicable in the companies cases also. Protection of minority shareholders is an important aspect of good corporate governance. The main procedure available to a shareholder to protect himself personally is to petition the court for a remedy pursuant to. Companies act provides relief for prejudiced minority. The purpose of this paper is to compare the response in the uk, the usa and china to the need to provide effective protection in law to disgruntled minority shareholders. Minorities, shareholder and otherwise yale law school legal. Pdf protection of minority shareholders rights waqas. The study is designed to assist the european commission dg justice and consumers in assessing the eu approach to and policy on minority shareholder protection.
Corporate governance is based on majority rule, which although efficient, allows for possible abuse by the majority. However there are ways in which a minority shareholder might be protected, either by agreement with the other shareholders or by taking action through the courts in certain. Company law provides for remedy if the minority shareholders can show that the companys affairs are being conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the company or its shareholders to such an extent as to make it just and equitable to wind it up. Protection of minority shareholders solicitors at lawson. Pdf the current rights of minority shareholders in saudi. Sometimes a majority shareholders attempts to push a minority shareholder out of his company. Pdf this article aims at introducing the main changes brought by the new albanian company law on minority shareholders protection. A minority shareholder has certain statutory rights, depending on the size of its stake in the company. Protection of minority shareholder interests, cross. The burden of proof imposed on a claimant and the range of issues necessarily considered at this stage define the process within which the courts balance protection of the company from the cost and distraction of bogus actions on the one hand, and minority shareholders from unacceptable excesses of majority shareholder rule on the other. The inadequacy of the law has made it possible for controlling shareholders to expropriate corporate assets by using complex corporate.
874 1025 234 1308 1183 174 1545 1361 1512 665 1522 173 197 604 696 1454 162 1430 1258 1127 986 1661 1374 1236 1573 222 1096 725 1228 773 961 544 1156 1192 961 1400 755 1191 1197 40 784 585